In the wake of recent market volatility, with the DOW experiencing a significant 4,000-point decline between April 2nd and 4th, we've been closely monitoring short-term rental data for early signals of changing consumer behavior. While economic fluctuations are natural, understanding potential impacts can help industry professionals make informed decisions.
Based on historical patterns and current market indicators, here are the key trends vacation rental operators should monitor as economic uncertainties increase:
1. Decreased Consumer Spending
During recessions, discretionary spending typically declines as consumers prioritize essential expenses. This could lead to reduced bookings and lower average daily rates for vacation rentals.
Recent Data Point: On April 5th, Bookings in the United States decreased 20% year-over-year.
This 20% drop, and continuing decrease, suggests a meaningful shift in consumer behavior indicating travelers are actively adjusting their spending habits in response to economic concerns. The timing is particularly significant as it represents early-to-mid spring booking patterns, which often include summer vacation planning. A decline this pronounced could signal challenges for the upcoming high season if the trend continues.
2. Vulnerability to International Travel Decline
Travelers may opt for more affordable options, such as choosing domestic over international travel.
Major Risk Factor: A significant recession-related threat to the U.S. vacation rental market is the potential decline in international visitors. As the chart clearly illustrates, certain destinations derive substantial portions of their demand from international travelers. Washington D.C. (23%) and Orlando (19%) are particularly exposed to this risk, while Hawaii (12%) also faces moderate exposure.
Market Vulnerability: If economic conditions trigger a pullback in international travel to the United States — whether due to reduced discretionary spending abroad, unfavorable exchange rates, or general economic uncertainty — destinations heavily dependent on non-U.S. visitors will likely experience disproportionate impacts. Conversely, primarily domestic markets like 30A (1%) face minimal exposure to international travel fluctuations, though they remain vulnerable to domestic economic conditions.
Most notably, in data published by the International Trade Administration, U.S. citizen departures (red line) show a recent downturn. This emerging reversal suggests Americans may be beginning to reconsider international travel plans in light of economic uncertainties.
Meanwhile, foreign citizen arrivals to the U.S. (blue line) continue to lag behind pre-pandemic benchmarks, remaining 13% below 2019 levels as of March 2025. Despite showing gradual improvement over the last few years, these rates have started to drop in the past few weeks.
We anticipate that changes in currency exchange rates, with the USD showing recent weakness, combined with evolving international perceptions of the United States, may further influence these travel patterns. The recent pullback in outbound travel, following two years of robust outbound travel to Europe, suggests we may see more U.S. travelers choosing domestic destinations.
3. Property Investment Challenges
Property owners may face cash flow issues if bookings decline while mortgage payments and maintenance costs remain steady.
4. Market Consolidation
Smaller vacation rental operators might struggle more than larger platforms with greater financial reserves, potentially leading to industry consolidation.
5. Varied Impact by Segment
Traditionally, during periods of recession, Luxury vacation rentals might see steeper declines, while budget-friendly options may remain relatively stable or even see increased demand. However, recent data suggests a more complex picture emerging.
Recent Data Points:
- Between 4/2 and 4/7, booked paid occupancy is 20% lower YoY for smaller properties vs. 15% lower YoY for larger properties
- Between 4/2 and 4/7, booking windows are 14% shorter for smaller properties vs. 8% shorter for larger properties
Forward Looking: Higher-Priced Properties Show Greater Resilience
A significant bright spot for luxury properties emerges when examining Adjusted RevPAR (Adjusted Revenue Per Available Rental) trends across different price tiers. Properties commanding nightly rates above $1,000 are actually showing a 1% YoY increase in adjusted RevPAR for Q2 and Q3 2025 bookings made by April 7. This contrasts sharply with budget accommodations ($0-$200 nightly rate), which are experiencing a severe 5% RevPAR decline.
This data strongly suggests that the luxury segment's clientele is less affected by current economic concerns, while budget-conscious travelers are responding more dramatically to financial pressures. Property managers of higher-end inventory may be better positioned to weather current market conditions, while those managing budget-friendly accommodations should prepare for more significant revenue impacts.
These trends create operational challenges as revenue becomes less predictable and more concentrated closer to stay dates, while the significant occupancy declines will likely trigger competitive pricing responses as property owners compete for a shrinking pool of travelers.
6. Regional Differences
Areas dependent on business travel might face greater challenges than leisure destinations, especially those accessible by car rather than air travel.
Recent Data Points:
- Bookings in Hawaii are down 22% YoY
- Bookings in 30A, Florida are up 3% YoY
- Bookings in the New York City Metro Area are consistent with last year
Hawaii's significant 22% decline indicates that high-cost, long-haul destinations may be experiencing the first wave of recession-related travel cutbacks.
By monitoring these key indicators, vacation rental professionals can better position themselves to weather potential economic challenges ahead.
Contact us to learn how you can access real-time market data with the click of a button to stay on top of developing trends in your community and across the STR industry.